When a group of medical specialists graduated, they decided to start a practice together. To help get things off the ground, one of the founders offered the group an unoccupied commercial suite they owned in a busy area, setting the initial rent well below market rates.
On day one, it was a great incentive.
The Complication: When a Deal Becomes a Trap
Ten years later, that initial arrangement had become a major financial and operational burden. While the starting rent was low, the long-term contract included fixed escalations that eventually pushed the lease significantly above market rates. Because the landlord was also a partner, discussing a rent reduction felt personal, and the group lacked any formal mechanism to renegotiate.
The Business Hit a Wall
- Slow Growth: Growth was slower than expected by the founders and the practice struggled to attract and retain patients despite the attractive local market.
- Unprofitable Operations: High rent ate up the clinic’s margins. As a result, the practice paid its doctors below-market rates for their clinical work.
- High Turnover: Frustrated by low pay, young doctors joined, stayed a few years, and left.
- Cultural Burnout: A sense of unfairness over the rent deal soured the clinic's culture, leaving both the medical and administrative teams demotivated.
The Resolution: Governance and Structural Realignment
To fix the business, the partners had to separate property ownership from practice operations. They resolved the crisis through three pragmatic steps:
- Establishing Formal Governance: The partners implemented a formal partnership agreement with explicit governance rules. This included a mandate that any related-party transactions (like renting a property from a partner) must be reviewed every two years against independent market appraisals, removing personal emotion from business decisions.
- Re-anchoring the Lease to Market: Using an independent valuation, the landlord agreed to reset the rent to current market rates.
- Reinvesting the Savings: The overhead savings were split into two strategic buckets:
- Growth: The remaining savings were channeled into a targeted marketing budget to attract new patients and grow the patient base.
- Doctor Retention: A pathway to level doctor compensation to market standards was implemented to stop the turnover.
Outcomes: With fair pay and a clear marketing strategy, patient volume grew and doctor turnover stopped. Fixing the governance didn't just stabilize the clinic's finances—it restored trust and motivation across the entire team.
Takeaway
Early-stage favors shouldn't dictate long-term commercial realities. When starting a practice with colleagues, robust governance and regular market-benchmarking aren't bureaucratic hurdles—they are essential tools to protect both the business and your professional relationships.
Important Note: Special thanks to the practice partners for allowing me to share this case study anonymously so others can learn from their experience.