We check reviews for dinner. Why not for a doctor?
Before you book a table at a new restaurant, you probably open Google Maps. You glance at the star rating, scroll through a few recent reviews and decide in under a minute.
Your patients now do exactly the same thing before they book with you. Google Maps has become the default way people find and judge a local service, and a medical practice is a local service.
The numbers keep moving in one direction. BrightLocal's 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey found that 41% of consumers always check reviews before choosing a local business, up from 29% a year earlier. Nearly a third (31%) will now only use a business rated 4.5 stars or higher, up from 17%. And 74% look for reviews written in the last three months. The survey is of US adults, but anyone who runs a practice in Sydney or Melbourne will recognise the behaviour.
Patients say it themselves. One reviewer in the examples we collected wrote: "Please read the reviews and do your own research before making an appointment. I wish I had."
A generational shift, not a passing trend
This is not a fad that will fade. It's a change in behaviour that moves with each generation of patients.
The older patients of a generation ago rarely looked anyone up. They found a doctor through their GP's referral, a friend or the phone book, and often stayed for decades. Today's patients in their fifties are different. They have spent twenty years booking flights, choosing hotels and comparing tradespeople online, and they bring the same habits to their healthcare. A GP referral still carries weight, but more and more patients check the name on it before they book.
Within a decade, those patients will be in their sixties and seventies, the age group that relies most on specialist and procedural care. The patients who matter most to many practices are becoming the ones most likely to read reviews first. Practices that start building their online reputation now will be ready for them. Those that wait will be catching up.
The blind spot: most doctors never look
Many doctors treat Google reviews as noise. Medicine is about clinical outcomes, not star ratings, so why bother? The trouble is that patients don't separate the two. When principals finally search for their own practice, they're often surprised. Some have no reviews at all. Others have a handful, and the handful is bad.
To see what patients actually find, we pulled a collection of one-star Google reviews of real GP clinics, specialist rooms and optometrists. They came from inner Sydney, regional Queensland, Perth, Adelaide, Alice Springs and Melbourne. We've left out the practice and staff names. What stands out is how little of it is about clinical care:
- The front desk. Reception comes up more than anything else. "Reception experience here is TERRIBLE. The doctors are OKAY, but the receptionist is extremely RUDE." Another wrote: "First impressions matter."
- Waiting without being told. "Arrived at 10:55 for an 11:00 appointment, 50 minutes later and I'm still waiting to be called in, no mention of there being a wait." The complaint is often the silence, not the delay.
- Fees that come as a surprise. Several reviewers were shocked by gap fees, late fees or extra charges they weren't warned about. "Money grabbing" appears again and again.
- Feeling unheard. "I didn't feel listened." "I left this appointment feeling dismissed and frustrated."
- Admin that breaks down. Results that never came back, appointments cancelled by text that never arrived, new patients turned away. There was even a triage conversation held loud enough for the whole waiting room to hear.
Nearly all of this can be fixed with process and training. None of it says much about the quality of the medicine. Yet for a prospective patient, these reviews are the practice.
The reviews also show how not to respond. In one case, a receptionist phoned the reviewer to ask them to take a one-star review down. The reviewer added an update saying so, and the review is still up. A short, professional public reply would have done far more good.
An intangible asset that takes years to build
A strong Google profile is an asset of the business, much like goodwill or a referral network. It doesn't appear on the balance sheet, but it's real, and buyers and incoming partners increasingly look at it.
What makes it valuable is that it can't be bought or rushed. A competitor can match your fit-out, your equipment and your fees within a year. They can't match 300 genuine, recent, mostly five-star reviews built over a decade. Getting there takes time and consistency: asking every patient, month after month.
The opposite is just as true. A practice with eight reviews and a 2.9 rating is fragile. Each new complaint has an outsized effect, and one bad week at reception can shape the practice's public image for years.
For local practices this is one of the few real differentiators left. Patients rarely have the information to compare doctors clinically. They can compare 4.8 stars from 400 reviews with 3.1 stars from 12, and they do.
Your Google profile is your reputation
For most new patients, the Google Maps listing is the first thing they see of your practice, before the website, the phone call or the waiting room. It's your reputation, visible to anyone, 24 hours a day.
It affects three things directly:
- New patients. A strong rating and a steady flow of recent reviews convert searches into bookings. A weak one quietly sends people to the practice down the road, and you never find out they were looking.
- Referrers. GPs, optometrists and allied health providers check too. A specialist with a poor or empty profile is a harder name to put on a referral, especially when the patient will look them up anyway.
- Reputation. Reviews are public, permanent and searchable. They shape how patients, colleagues and prospective staff see the practice long after the visit itself.
Several reviewers in our sample made the link explicitly: they read the other reviews, saw the pattern and decided to go elsewhere. That decision is happening every day, in every suburb, without the practice in the room.
What to do about it
Building a strong Google Maps presence isn't complicated. It just has to be done consistently, as part of how the practice runs.
-
Claim and complete your Google Business Profile. Add the correct hours, phone number, address, parking and accessibility details, and photos of the rooms and team. List each consulting doctor where that's appropriate.
-
Ask every patient, every time. Most happy patients never think to leave a review, while unhappy ones usually do. Send a polite review link by SMS or email after the appointment, and make it part of the workflow rather than an occasional push. Practice Alliance Reviews, our review-request software, automates this step. It sends each patient a review request after their visit, so asking for reviews happens consistently instead of depending on whether the front desk remembers.
-
Stay within the rules. Under AHPRA's advertising guidelines, practitioners must not use testimonials in their own advertising. Don't offer incentives for reviews, and don't copy reviews onto your website or social media. Simply asking patients to leave honest feedback on Google is fine.
-
Reply to every review, good and bad. Keep it short, polite and general. Never confirm that the person is a patient or mention any clinical detail, because privacy obligations still apply. Offer to take the conversation offline. Never call a reviewer to ask them to remove a review.
-
Treat negative reviews as free audits. Our examples are, in effect, a list of front-desk, scheduling, wait-times and billing problems. Review the feedback monthly with the practice manager and fix the patterns, not just the individual complaint.
-
Measure it. Track rating, review count and how many reviews arrived in the last 90 days alongside your other practice KPIs.
Start building it now
We would never let our rooms fall into disrepair, with a broken sign at the door, a dirty waiting room and nobody at the desk. Yet that's what many practices' Google profiles look like to the patients searching for them today.
Google reviews are slow to build and quick to damage. That's exactly what makes them valuable. Practices that invest now, consistently and within the rules, will have an asset their competitors can't catch up to quickly. The ones that ignore it will keep wondering why the phone isn't ringing.
Search for your own practice on Google Maps today, and look at it the way a new patient would.
Frequently asked questions
Do patients really use Google reviews to choose a doctor?
Yes. Patients increasingly check Google Maps reviews before booking a GP, specialist or optometrist, just as they would before choosing a restaurant. BrightLocal's 2026 survey found 41% of consumers always check reviews before choosing a local business, and 31% will only use businesses rated 4.5 stars or higher.
Do older patients check online reviews?
Increasingly, yes. Patients in their fifties have spent decades booking and comparing services online, and they apply the same habits to healthcare. As they move into their sixties and seventies, the age group that relies most on specialist and procedural care, the share of patients who check reviews before booking will keep growing.
Why does my medical practice have so few Google reviews?
Most satisfied patients never think to leave a review unless they're asked, while unhappy patients often review without being asked. Practices that don't ask regularly end up with few reviews, and the ones they do have are more likely to be negative.
What do negative reviews of medical practices usually complain about?
Mostly non-clinical problems. In one-star reviews of Australian practices analysed by Practice Alliance, the most common complaints were rude reception staff, long waits with no explanation, unexpected fees, feeling unheard, and admin failures such as lost results or cancelled appointments.
Are Google reviews an asset for a medical practice?
Yes. A strong Google profile is an intangible business asset, like goodwill or a referral network. It takes years of consistent effort to build, competitors can't copy it quickly, and it brings in new patients and referrers.
Can doctors in Australia ask patients for Google reviews?
Yes. Practices can ask patients to leave honest feedback on Google. Under AHPRA's advertising guidelines, practitioners must not use testimonials in their own advertising. That means no incentives for reviews and no reposting reviews on the practice website or social media.
How should a doctor respond to a negative Google review?
Reply publicly, briefly and politely, without confirming the person is a patient or mentioning any clinical detail. Offer to continue the conversation privately. Never pressure the reviewer to remove the review.
How can a medical practice get more Google reviews?
Ask every patient after every visit with a simple review link by SMS or email. Software such as Practice Alliance Reviews automates these requests so they go out consistently, without relying on reception staff to remember.
Do Google reviews affect referrals from other doctors?
They can. GPs, optometrists and allied health providers often check a specialist's online profile before referring, knowing the patient will look them up too. A poor or empty profile makes a referral harder.